28 Comments
User's avatar
Darcy Green's avatar

This was absolutely what I needed to read this morning!

Expand full comment
Sarah Zachrich Jeng's avatar

Totally related to this. Writing my second novel under contract and alternately hating and loving the process taught me that I'd rather be joyful and slow than productive and have it be a slog. And I remember those days of discovery in my fanfic years too (graphic design actually WAS my passion, lol). Trying to get a little bit of that back.

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

I'm so happy it resonated! Book 2 under contract is so hard. And yes, joy is such a better place to write from than obligation or misery.

Expand full comment
Swati Teerdhala's avatar

I loved this so much, it was exactly the right message I needed today as I'm slogging through what I hope is my next book. 💕

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

I’m so glad it was helpful!

Expand full comment
Aurora Palit's avatar

I needed to read this. Thank you for putting this into the world - I know it's not easy to share thoughts like this publically.

Expand full comment
Maggie Rapier's avatar

This was deeply, deeply helpful to read—thank you! Both my best friend and I come from fanfic, and as I’ve been slogging my way through my sophomore novel, this conversation has come up more than once. Thank you for your insight!

Expand full comment
Emma ✽ Away Message's avatar

Loved this piece, Regina — it really hit home for me. I very much resonate with this: "Nothing used to intimidate me. The only test for whether I could write something was whether I loved it enough." Cheers to tapping back into that mindset, or at least trying to!

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

Thank you Emma! It’s a work in progress

Expand full comment
Julie Cassidy's avatar

As a former LiveJournal fanfiction writer (and blogger! I got so much joy from just writing about my life!), I loved this. My “loves list” I posted about recently was all about joy and remembering writing can be fun — and having fun is why I started writing as a kid in the first place.

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

Yes! Fun really was the point and while making it a career does add another dimension, it should be the feeling that guides a lot of the decisions we make in this industry.

Expand full comment
Alicia Thompson's avatar

CAN I FIT THIS ENTIRE NEWSLETTER INTO A POST-IT TO KEEP AT MY DESK?! I don't know but I'm going to try. I love this reframe, too: "Do I love X enough to create my version of it?" I do think it's more "fun" when you're keeping all of this in mind!!

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

I was so fearless back then! Lately I’ve been asking myself “Am I having fun” when I sit down to do anything writing related.

Expand full comment
Emily Charlotte's avatar

Accuracy, not marketability!! YES!!!! (Also: the LiveJournal origin story! Those were the days!)

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

Can we rewind time a little and revive LJ? I think we could all use some of that magic right now

Expand full comment
Annie McQuaid's avatar

I loved this advice so much! Definitely something I needed to hear and keep in mind as I'm writing book 2!

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

I’m so happy it resonated! And good luck with book 2!

Expand full comment
Alyssa Jarrett's avatar

Love this! I also say the same about book marketing—if it's not fun, I don't wanna do it!

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

I’ve embrace this thinking this time around and I’m so much happier

Expand full comment
Kim Golden's avatar

Writing stopped being fun for me for a while. For a lot of different reasons but one of the main ones was trying to write to market and hating it. I did it because everyone kept telling me that it would build my platform, improve my discoverability, yada yada. It killed the joy for me. So now I've gone back to writing as slowly as I need to, writing what I want to write, and being happy.

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

Yes! Why are we doing this if it’s not making us happy? That should be the goal.

Expand full comment
Kim Golden's avatar

Good question! I think a lot of writers think writing = money. For me, making money from my writing was a bonus. I just want to write and enjoy what I’m doing.

Expand full comment
Kim Golden's avatar

Exactly! I know we are always told we should want to hit the bestseller's list, but if if means that you hate what you're writing... then what is the point???

Expand full comment
Maggie North's avatar

"writing to please everyone produces something as generic as bottled water, where only packaging distinguishes yours from the rest" dear GOD Regina can you please give us 24 hours of notice before hitting us with a truth like this <3 <3 <3

Expand full comment
Denise Williams's avatar

Beautiful. I love this and it’s spot on. It’s so devastatingly easy for the fun to disappear.

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

SO easy for the fun to evaporate. We really need to protect that feeling

Expand full comment
Nikki Payne's avatar

If this were fun... This is beautiful! This is such a great way to reimagine your writing path and also infuse Joy into those processes. I think everyone has to think about what their writing life will look like if it were fun.

Expand full comment
Regina Black's avatar

This really was a great exercise for me and it’s really impacting how I think about all of this.

Expand full comment